Skip to Main Content

Benghazi Ignored: New Evidence Exposes Gaps in Kabul Embassy Security

The private security force tasked with defending the U.S. Embassy in war-torn Afghanistan has been chronically understaffed, leaving the compound at risk, former guards told the Project On Government Oversight (POGO). Previously unpublished documents obtained by POGO buttress their accounts.

POGO’s investigation also shows that a top State Department official delivered inaccurate and misleading testimony to a Senate panel in July, when he dismissed concerns about security at the U.S. Embassy in Kabul. Undersecretary of State Patrick Kennedy, who oversees diplomatic security, said “the proof is in the pudding” and the contractor now responsible for protecting the embassy had proven itself by twice rebuffing enemy attacks on the compound. The events he described never happened.

The weaknesses in the embassy’s defenses are especially troubling because they have continued long after last year’s deadly attack in Benghazi focused Washington on the stakes. Now, U.S. diplomatic posts around the world face heightened risks amid threats of retaliation for a potential U.S. strike on Syria, the one-year anniversary of Benghazi and the anniversary of 9-11.

Former employees of Aegis Defense Services, the embassy’s security contractor, agreed to speak on the record because of their concerns about the safety of the embassy and its personnel.

J.P. Antonio, a former Aegis medic, told POGO that understaffing and other security problems were chronic since he began working for the company in Kabul in May 2012.

“If the embassy were attacked, we’d have a huge problem and I don’t want to think about the casualties,” Antonio said.

Thomas Boggs, a former shift leader of Aegis’ Emergency Response Team, told POGO the guard force was significantly short of key staff, including supervisors, medics and members of the Emergency Response Team.

The new information is all the more remarkable because former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and her successor, John Kerry, have spoken forcefully of the need to bolster protection for U.S. diplomatic installations around the world.

In the Afghan capital, Aegis has been protecting the U.S. embassy since the middle of last year. The company is operating under a State Department contract that the department has said could be worth $457 million over multiple years. More than 1,500 diplomats and staff members at the U.S. embassy compound have been depending on the company.

Click to read POGO’s report on the embassy and POGO's story about Patrick Kennedy's testimony.

By: Joe Newman
Director of Communications, POGO

joe newman Joe Newman is the Director of Communications for the Project On Government Oversight.

Topics: Contract Oversight

Related Content: Contractor Accountability, Defense, Embassy Guards, Federal Contractor Misconduct, Private Security Contractors, State Department

Authors: Joe Newman

Submitted by Dockrat13 at: September 15, 2013
And just why are we paying contractors (big bucks) to the a US Marines job? Traditionally this was considered an honor and a privilege to guard a US Embassy. Why has this changed?
Submitted by Ironman5 at: September 14, 2013
It's obvious that when you hire a for profit company for anything, they will try to maximize their profit by cutting expenses wherever they can. In this case it was in man power. Starting with Reagan and exemplified by G.W.Bush, privatization of our armed services has led directly to this tragedy in Benghazi. To date, I have not heard one Pol say this.
Submitted by Fla Birder at: September 14, 2013
Why aren't our embassies being guarded by the United States Marines instead of civilian contractors? The fact that civilian contractors & not the Marines are guarding out embassies is why 4 people were killed in Benghazi. If a detatchment of Marines had been at the embassy, chances are excellent that the only lives lost would have been the attackers. Every American Embassy in the world should be guarded by a fully armed detatchment of Marines.

Leave A Comment

Enter this word: Change

Related Posts

Browse POGOBlog by Topic

POGO on Facebook

POGOBlog Contributors

See All Blog Contributors

Latest Podcast

Podcast; Social Media, Internet Provides Opportunities, Challenges for Lawmakers

The Congressional Management Foundation offers the Gold Mouse Awards annually to members of Congress who make the most of the opportunity the digital world offers them. POGO spoke with members of Rep. Mike Honda's communications team about their award.