Skip to Main Content
FacebookTwitter
Share on Facebook
CURRENT_PAGE_TITLE
Cancel
Share on Yahoo!
CURRENT_PAGE_TITLE
Cancel
Share on MySpace
CURRENT_PAGE_TITLE
Cancel
Share on Twitter
A short url will be added to the end of your Tweet.

Cancel
Share on LinkedIn
CURRENT_PAGE_TITLE
Cancel
 


Federal Contractor Misconduct

POGO Files 

Related Resources (government documents and letters)

POGO in the News


POGO Files

Podcast: How Bad Performance Can Be Good for Business in Government Contracting
March 7, 2011

POGO's Scott Amey dishes out a post-mortem on a recent Commission on Wartime Contracting hearing--at which he testified--on contractor accountability.


Majority of Top Contractors Could be Defunded by House Legislation
September 29, 2009

A survey of data from POGO's Federal Contractor Misconduct Database shows that 62 federal contractors have been involved in instances that might prohibit them from receiving future federal funds if the "Defund ACORN Act" becomes law.


7-Day Itch
April 3, 2008

7-Day Itch
April 3, 2008

POGO makes comment on Contractor Compliance Program and Integrity Reporting
January 14, 2008

POGO supports contractor compliance program and integrity reporting, but the proposed rule’s mandatory reporting requirement must be clarified and expanded to require contractors to disclose a broader array of unethical conduct.


Suspension and debarment: The record shows that the system is broken
March 21, 2005

Not surprisingly, many federal suspension and debarment officials have claimed the system is working. It's not.  Critics of the contractor suspension and debarment system, including the Project On Government Oversight for which I work, have made a strong case that the system is in disarray, is stacked heavily against small contractors, and is applied subjectively. According to the government's own data, of the 43,000 individuals, businesses and contractors currently banned from doing future business with the government, none is a large contractor.  In the past, POGO has illustrated the application of the suspension and debarment system in favor of large contractors. POGO's research found that from 1990 to 2003, the top 10 federal contractors had a total of 280 instances of misconduct or alleged misconduct and paid more than $2.97 billion in fines, penalties, restitution, settlements and cleanup costs. POGO sent Freedom of Information Act requests to 12 agencies for suspension or debarment records regarding their top contractors. Although POGO found multiple instances of contractor misconduct for many of those contractors, only one agency responded that it had records indicating that the specified contractors were ever considered for suspension or debarment. As a side note, one agency — the Agriculture Department — is still processing POGO's 2001 FOIA request.  …  The suspension and debarment system clearly does not work, and the government needs to do more than deny the problem — the American public must be protected from risky contractors, both large and small.  


Boeing's Rap Sheet
June 9, 2003

Federal Contractor Misconduct: Failures of the Suspension and Debarment System
May 10, 2002

Many of the U.S. government's largest contractors have been found to have repeatedly broken the law or engaged in misconduct, according to POGO's investigation. However, they are never even temporarily suspended, let alone debarred, from gaining additional government contracts, contrary to Reagan/Bush era laws. POGO's research found that, since 1990, 43 of the government's top contractors paid approximately $3.4 billion in fines/penalties, restitution, and settlements. Furthermore, four of the top 10 government contractors have at least two criminal convictions. And yet, only one of the top 43 contractors has been suspended or debarred from doing business with the government, and then, for only five days. Our report includes recommendations to improve the system to ensure that taxpayer dollars are not awarded to contractors with long rap sheets.


Top

 

Related Resources


House panel weighs contracting reform legislation
By Elizabeth Newell, Government Executive
February 26, 2008 


Review of GSA’s Suspension and Debarment Program
, GSA Report Number A070105/O/A/F08004
December 20, 2007 


DHS Compilation of Contractor Performance Databases
Elaine C. Duke, Chief Procurement Officer, Department of Homeland Security
August 7, 2007 


Thousands of GSA Contractors Abuse the Federal Tax System
, Government Accountability Office
March 14, 2006 


Top


POGO in the News


The Record: Letters, Dec. 20, 2011, Paula RogovinNorthJersey.com, December 20, 2011 


Siemens Pivots To Thrive In US After Bribery Settlement, Samuel RubenfeldThe Wall Street Journal, December 15, 2011 


Repeal of contractor tax withholding is sign of economic times, With POGO's Scott AmeyFederalNewsRadio.com, October 28, 2011 


Repeal of 3 percent contractor tax withholding gathers steam, Charles S. ClarkGovernment Executive (govexec.com), October 24, 2011 


Lawmakers push Defense fraud, waste report to influence supercommittee cuts, John T. BennettThe Hill, October 23, 2011 


Army Corps bribery arrests praised by lawmakers, Charles S. ClarkGovernment Executive (govexec.com), October 5, 2011 


Medicare Decides It Takes a Thief to Catch a Thief, Reuben GuttmanAccounting Today, July 29, 2011 


Contractor accused of negligence in soldier deaths, Richard Lardner, Associated PressBusiness Week, July 12, 2011 


Small-Town Mayor Claims Funding For Firehouse Held Up By Opposition To Mining , Marcus BaramThe Huffington Post, June 15, 2011 


Delinquent government contractors, Nancy Marshall GenzerAmerican Public Media; Marketplace, May 24, 2011 


Earl Industries' $75M Navy contract: What went wrong?, Robert McCabeThe Virginian-Pilot, May 16, 2011 


Gov't Paying Firm Lodged With Job Discrimination Suit, WBALTV; 11 Investigates I-Team, May 12, 2011 


Sunshine advocates criticize government contractor database, By Joseph MarksNextGov, May 3, 2011 


BP Still Being Awarded Lucrative Government Contracts, By Jason LeopoldTruthout; The Public Record, April 21, 2011 


Big Break For Big Oil, Larger Burden For Taxpayers, By Aaron MehtaThe Huffington Post; iWatch News, April 15, 2011 


Contractor database goes public - with limits, By Sarah ChackoFederal Times, April 15, 2011 


O'Keefe vs. NPR: Round One Goes to the Kid, By Brian PalmerThe Huffington Post, March 14, 2011 


Wartime panel: Get tougher on bad contractors, By Sarah ChackoFederal Times, March 6, 2011 


What POGO learned from a contracting panel, By Matthew WeigeltFederal Computer Week, March 4, 2011 


OFPP's Gordon shy about opening meeting results, By Matthew WeigeltFederal Computer Week (fcw.com), March 2, 2011 


Report: Wartime Contractors Waste, Steal Tens Of Billions -- Then Come Back For More, By Dan FroomkinThe Huffington Post, February 28, 2011 


Bumpy road to Boeing tanker contract, By Steve GiegerichSt. Louis Today, February 26, 2011 


Why Should Firms That Spied on Unions Keep Government Contracts?, By Mike ElkIn These Times, February 24, 2011 


Contractors nervous about public access to database of past problems, By Marjorie CenserThe Washington Post, February 21, 2011 


In the Dark: Crimes, Capital Crimes, And GE Capital Crimes, By Richard (RJ) Eskow The Huffington Post, February 10, 2011 


POGO argues for release of past-performance information, By Matthew WeigeltFederal Computer Week; FCW.com, January 28, 2011 


Fed contractors' history could be open to public in April, By Matthew Weigelt and Alice LipowiczWashington Technology, January 24, 2011 


Tomgram: William Hartung, Lockheed Martin's Shadow Government, By Tom EngelhardtOEN: opednews.com, January 11, 2011 


Some Government Contractors are Too Big to be Banned, By Noel Brinkerhoff and David WallechinskyAllGov.com, December 20, 2010 


Federal Contractors Under Scrutiny, By Heide B. MalhotraThe Epoch Times, October 5, 2010 


More Contracts Flood KBR (KBR) with Cash Despite a Questionable Reputation, By Leo SunInvestorguide.com, September 23, 2010 


Contractor performance data to become public, By Tom SpothFederal Times.com, August 6, 2010 


Industry group fears publicizing contractor database could backfire, By Robert BrodskyGovernment Executive, August 6, 2010 


New law puts contractor performance in the public spotlight, By Matthew WeigeltWashington Technology, August 5, 2010 


New law requires OMB to post information on contractors, By Aliya SternsteinNextgov; Technology And The Business Of Government, August 4, 2010 


Contractor Misconduct Database updated, With Suzanne KubotaFederal News Radio 1500 AM, April 27, 2010 


Watchdog group seeks better-quality contract data, By Tom SpothFederal Times.com, April 23, 2010 


A missed opportunity for accountablity from the Obama administration, By Matthew WeigeltFederal Computer Week, March 24, 2010 


Acquisition councils create database to track contractor misdeeds, By Elizabeth NewellGovernment Executive, March 23, 2010 


Government Contractors' Free Ride Is Over; Serious accountability is here to stay at last., By POGO's Scott Amey and Danielle BrianForbes.com; Ethisphere, March 16, 2010 


The Nation: The Contractor Scofflaws, By William GreiderNational Public Radio (NPR), March 8, 2010 


Flawed Nuke Detection Program Dialed-Back by DHS, By Tom BurghardtPacific Free Press, February 28, 2010 


Should better paying contractors have a competitive advantage?, By Matthew WeigeltWashington Technology, February 26, 2010 


POGO: Contracting executive order a positive step, With Chris Dorobek and Amy MorrisFederal News Radio, January 21, 2010 


Contract cons can exploit Transportation delay, By Jim McElhattonWashington Times, January 13, 2010 


Why Is the Government Paying Companies Fined for Pollution and Accused of Fraud?, By Will EvansCalifornia Watch/AlterNet, January 11, 2010 


Obama Promise #30, By Wes AllisonSt. Petersburg Times; PolitiFact.com, January 6, 2010 


The Federal Drive, With Tom Temin & Jane NorrisTuesday Morning Federal Newscast (WFED), November 10, 2009 


New contractor database draws fire, By Alice LipowiczFederal Computer Week, November 9, 2009 


Two stimulus contractors suspended from government work, By Marcus GreenLouisville Courier-Journal, November 9, 2009 


Stimulus dollars going to accused contractors, By Kimberly KindyThe Washington Post, October 29, 2009 


Stimulus Contracts Go to Companies Under Criminal Investigation, By Michael GrabellProPublica, October 25, 2009 


Defense firms in probe received $30M in stimulus money, By Michael Grabell, ProPublicaUSA Today, October 25, 2009 


The Acorn Standard, By Jeremy ScahillThe Nation, October 14, 2009 


Pentagon Fraud and the ACORN Standard, Los Angeles Chronicle, October 2, 2009 


Its Not Just ACORN, Says Congressman Grayson, By Katherine WellsThe Huffington Post, October 2, 2009 


Bills to Defund ACORN Face Legal Hurdles, Experts Say, FoxNews.com, October 1, 2009 


ACORN to lose funding?, With Dylan RatiganMSNBC TV Morning Meeting, October 1, 2009 


ACORN Donations Dwindle In Wake Of Videos, by Pam FesslerNPR, All Things Considered, October 1, 2009 


Defunding ACORN faces surprise hurdles, By Stephan DinanThe Washington Times, September 30, 2009 


Congress Cracks Down on Defense Fraud: But it was just by accident, By Ken SilversteinHarper’s’ Magazine, September 30, 2009 


OOPS! The ACORN Ban Could Snag Lockheed & Catholic Charities, By Laura FlandersThe Nation Magazine; Blog: The Notion, September 25, 2009 


Editorial: If you thought ACORN was bad ..., Dallas Morning News, September 23, 2009 


Contractor integrity, performance to face higher level of scrutiny, By Jason MillerFederal News Radio, September 4, 2009 


How Federal Contracts Waste Taxpayers' Money, Parade Magazine, July 19, 2009 


SAIC faces challenge in False Claims defense, By Alice LipowiczWashington Technology, July 8, 2009 


GAO: Despite efforts, gaps remain in data on contractors, By Elizabeth Newell Government Executive, May 27, 2009 


Lockheed lands atop ranking in defense dollars, misconduct cases, By Richard BurnettThe Orlando Sentinel, April 23, 2009 


POGO Updates Contractor Misconduct Database, Defense Industry Daily/Online, April 22, 2009 


Group updates federal contractor misconduct database, By Alice LipowiczWashington Technology, April 21, 2009 


POGO: Penalized contractors kept winning contracts, By Alice LipowiczWashington Technoligy, March 29, 2009 


President Orders Review of Federal Contracting System More Competition, Accountability for Procurement Sought, By Scott Wiilson and Robert O'Harrow, Jr.The Washington Post, March 5, 2009 


Obama Supports Acquisition Reform Bill, By John M. DoyleAviation Week, March 5, 2009 


When suspending contractors, size - not action - matters, By Elise CastelliFederal Times, March 2, 2009 


More Procurement Reform, By Robert O’HarrowWashington Post Online, January 13, 2009 


Paper urges tougher controls on contractors, By Alice LipowiczFederal Computer Week, January 13, 2009 


Burnett Tainted by Army Billing Fiasco, By Jeremy Mullman and Ira TeinowitzAD Age, January 12, 2009 


A firm voice on the Hill, By Alice LipowiczWashington Technology, January 12, 2009 


Contractor watchdog updates misconduct database, By Alice LipowiczWashington Technology, November 4, 2008 


Annals of Crony Capitalism, Nuke Detection Machines Fail, Again, By Tom BurghardtGlobal Research, November 4, 2008 


Defense awards more Iraq reconstruction work to contractors cited for poor performance, By Elizabeth NewellGovernment Executive, October 28, 2008 


List of federal contractors and their misdeeds is just a click away, By Mark MahoneyGlens Falls Post-Star, October 15, 2008 


Abu Ghraib: The Outsourcing of Torture, By Tom BurghardtGlobal Research, July 6, 2008 


Action Tougher Than Oversight, By Matthew BlakeThe Washington Independent, June 17, 2008 


Outsourcing The Fight, By P.W. SingerForbes.com, June 6, 2008 


Access to contractor misconduct database restricted in Senate bill, By Robert BrodskyGov Exec, May 21, 2008 


Surge of potential acquisition bills, rulemaking spark comments, By Michael BrunoAerospace Daily & Defense Report, April 29, 2008 


Tracking the Spoils of the Private Sector, EditorialThe New York Times, April 24, 2008 


Today's Spotlight: A Contractor Misconduct Database, By Andrew B. EinhornOhmygov.com, April 23, 2008 


Maloney Federal Contractor Oversight Bill Passes House; Sen. McCaskill Introduces Companion Legislation, Meghan O’Shaughnessy (Maloney Press Officer)Congressional Documents and Publications U.S. Senate Documents, April 23, 2008 


NDIA Works To Kill Contractor-Misdeed Database, By William MatthewsDefense News, April 15, 2008 


IBM Bid Suspension Rattles Contractors; Influence, By Jeff HorwitzLegal Times, April 14, 2008 


EG&G deal: Contractor won HAFB missile contract despite poor record, By Matthew D. LaPlanteThe Salt Lake Tribune, April 9, 2008 


Ban on IBM contracting is lifted, By Elise CastelliFederal Times, April 4, 2008 


Turn Yourselves In, By Elizabeth NewellGovernment Executive, April 1, 2008 


U.S. used suspended security firm, By Jim McElhattonWashington Times, March 31, 2008 


GSA’s Alliant exemplifies common problem, By Elise CastelliFederal Times, March 23, 2008 


Top