Skip to main content

Analysis

Judge Sides with Marine in Information-Mishandling Case

A federal judge determined that a board of inquiry that had initially recommended Marine Corps Major Jason Brezler’s discharge for mishandling classified information in 2013 had unjustly withheld documents that would have been key to his defense.
By

Major Jason Brezler received a new opportunity to support his claims of retaliation by the Marines Corps. He had been discharged when a 2013 board of inquiry determined he had mishandled classified information.

Major Brezler had filed a lawsuit claiming he faced wrongful retaliation from the Corps “for contacting Capitol Hill about his concerns,” according to the Marine Corps Times. At the recommendation of a board of inquiry, Brezler had been discharged for using his personal email to send confidential documents that warned fellow Marines about a credible threat in Afghanistan.

Major Brezler fought a three-year battle to get his case heard in court, and last week a federal judge’s ruling overturned the Corps’ decision, concluding that “Major Brezler lacked the relevant documents necessary to fully and fairly litigate his retaliation claims” before the board of inquiry in 2013.

Because of this, Major Brezler will remain with the Corps and have the opportunity to support his claims of retaliation at a new board of inquiry hearing by the Navy.

As the Project On Government Oversight pointed out last year, Brezler’s punishment contrasts greatly with the treatment of elite officials accused of mishandling classified information. For example, while high-level officials only receive light taps on the wrist—as in the case of General David Petraeus who shared classified information with his biographer and mistress yet was only sentenced to two years’ probation and charged a fine he could easily afford to pay—a lower-ranked service member like Major Brezler was discharged for his effort to identify an eminent threat to his fellow Marines.

Iulia Gheorghiu

Iulia Gheorghiu is a Beth Daley fellow at POGO.

Oversight in your inbox

Weekly newsletter and updates

Hand holding a phone displaying POGO's Weekly Spotlight email on screen

Get the latest

Join our fight for a more effective and accountable government. Sign up for our Weekly Spotlight newsletter and occasional updates on POGO's work.

See our privacy policy

Oversight in your inbox

Join our fight for a more effective and accountable government. Sign up for our Weekly Spotlight newsletter and occasional updates on POGO's work.

See our privacy policy