Archived
Program Helps Marine Officers Develop Decision-Making Skills
This podcast series is no longer active and is preserved as an archive below.
Hosted by
Instructors at The Basic School, the Marine Corps’ six-month-long course for all newly commissioned officers, are using training methods used in institutions like Harvard Business School and Columbia University to make better decision-makers. The Case Method Project at Quantico, Virginia, uses decision-forcing exercises, or scenarios used to place students in the role of a person facing a difficult problem. These are based on historical events, and help develop the student officer’s ability to make and communicate rapid decisions in a stressful situation. It’s a break from the traditional “task-condition-standard” training method, which teaches students to execute a prescribed set of procedures based on the situation. The traditional method makes it easy for the institution to evaluate training and goes a long way to teaching people how to follow checklists, but it does little to foster the kind of adaptability and creativity one needs to be a truly effective leader.
On the day of my recent visit, approximately 80 students gathered in a classroom to participate in a decision-forcing exercise centered around the 2007 story of 3 Platoon from the 1st Battalion Royal Anglian Regiment. The platoon of 19 British soldiers led by Lt. Bjorn Rose were attacking into a Taliban held village in Helmand Province when suddenly the soldier at the head of the column was hit by enemy gunfire. Lt. Rose and his soldiers had to evacuate their wounded comrade through twisting streets to waiting medical help while the enemy continued attacking.
With the aid of maps and pictures taken at the time of the real event, instructors provided the students with information about the size of the force available to them, the kind of vehicles they had, and where the enemy forces were expected. It was then up to the students to decide how to move the casualty a mile back to the ambulance. The instructors created a stressful environment by blaring recorded gunfire in the background and acting the part of frantic soldiers shouting questions at them.
This kind of training is based on a deep understanding of adult learning. Extensive research in recent decades has shown that most adults learn best through experiential learning. Using these methods, students first experience a situation and then reflect on it through a discussion with the other students and the instructor. Only then do they move onto the conceptual stage where they receive the kind of classes most people would expect to receive at the beginning of the process. The usual task-condition-standard training method makes students come up with a predetermined “right” answer. But in a decision-forcing case, they must figure out how to solve the problem without first being told how. The instruction they receive later will reinforce the knowledge they have already gained through their experience.
Marine Major Scott Helminski and Damien O’Connell, Senior Fellow of the Marine Corps Case Method Project, explained the ideas behind this approach and described some of the results they have seen so far.
Innovative training and education methods of this kind represent a rejection of the outdated assembly-line methods that have been in use for more than a century. The old methods were based on the premise that all officers are interchangeable, just like a cog in a machine. So as long as each individual has gone through the proper training regimen, so the conventional wisdom goes, one officer is as good as another.
Breaking from that mindset is the first necessary step for the military to face all the challenges of the future. The character of modern warfare demands innovative officers capable of devising creative solutions to complex problems rather than simply following rigid checklists. Case studies and decision-forcing exercises help develop students’ critical thinking skills. In addition to enabling officers to make better decisions on the battlefield, these skills could help the officers later as they move up in rank to better challenge the current military system and make better decisions regarding budgets and the types of weapons the military purchases.
Show Notes
Scott Helminski - Guest Expert
Damien O’Connell - Guest Expert
Dan Grazier - Host
-
S01
Archived
Is the F-35 Program at a Crossroads?
The latest testing report on the F-35 details a simulation facility that doesn’t work, a leaking dam of design flaws, a new data network for F-35 that is in danger of failing, and a program that is still vulnerable to enemy hackers.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Telling the Truth About Afghanistan with Lt. Col. Danny Davis
Retired Army Lieutenant Colonel Danny Davis talks about the official lies told about the Afghanistan War, revealing the truth, and how America can forge a new foreign policy path moving forward.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
What’s the Military’s Role in a Contested Election, with Mark Nevitt
With the potential of unrest surrounding the upcoming election, Retired Navy Judge Advocate General and Syracuse Law professor Mark Nevitt talks about the laws governing the president’s authority to deploy the military within the United States.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Military Health Care Challenges with Dr. Robert Adams
Retired Army doctor Robert Adams talks about the consequences of the efforts to outsource the military’s health system over the past decade, despite repeated warnings from medical professionals.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Citizen-Soldiers Versus Soldier-Citizens with Dr. Steele Brand
The divide between America’s soldier-citizens and the society they serve has a significant impact on policy decisions and military budgets. History offers an effective alternative that would help eliminate that divide.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Corruption as a National Security Issue with Sarah Chayes
Corruption, often viewed as an obstacle that must be overcome to quell unrest around the world, is the real source of the unrest, according to journalist and national defense policy advisor Sarah Chayes.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Advising Foreign Forces with “Chipp” Naylon
Marine Corps Captain “Chipp” Naylon, who deployed as a military advisor with the Georgian Army to Afghanistan in 2014, offers insight into the often overlooked role of military advisors in our overseas campaigns.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Tactical Decision Games with Bruce Gudmundsson and Don Vandergriff
Preparing leaders for success on the modern battlefield requires innovative training approaches to develop their ability to handle the uncertain situations in which they will find themselves.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Classifying John Boyd with Chuck Spinney
Military scholars’ attempts to classify John Boyd as an airpower theorist are misguided, according to one of his closest collaborators.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
F-35 Far from Ready to Face Current or Future Threats, Testing Data Shows
The annual testing office report on the F-35 program shows little to no improvement in several key metrics for an effective aircraft program, and the Navy’s version is not ready for combat, contrary to the Pentagon’s recent announcement.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Mission Command with Bruce Gudmundsson and Don Vandergriff
Success on the modern battlefield requires leaders at all levels to use informed initiative to deal appropriately with the uncertain situations in which they will find themselves.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
“Who Killed Lt. Van Dorn?”
A new documentary looks into the case of Navy Lt. Wes Van Dorn who was killed alongside two crewmates when their Sea Dragon helicopter crashed off the coast of Virginia in January 2014 and details the institutional factors that led to the tragedy.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
F-35 Program Cutting Corners to “Complete” Development
Rather than actually fixing potentially serious F-35 design flaws, documents show, program officials are simply altering paperwork to make it appear as though the development process has been completed.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Jamie Schwandt, Grading the Army’s Staff College
Jamie Schwandt turned the tables on his instructions and the institution of the Army’s Command and General Staff College at Fort Leavenworth by publishing a rather scathing assessment of both.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Jeff Groom, Disillusioned Helicopter Pilot
Jeff Groom, a former Marine Corps helicopter pilot, talks about his experiences flying (and not flying), readiness, and the mismatch between what the services say they can do and what they can actually do.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
F-35: Still No Finish Line in Sight
The Project On Government Oversight wades through the complicated and sometimes vague language of the latest annual report by the Pentagon’s testing office, and provides the larger context.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Pierre Sprey and the Birth of the A-10, Part II
Pierre Sprey, part of the original design team to create one of the most iconic aircraft flying today, tells the unusual story of how it came to be.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Goliath Weapons Systems: Interview with Dan Grazier
Project On Government Oversight’s Dan Grazier spoke on Reuters War College podcast about over-budget weapon programs.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Pierre Sprey and the Birth of the A-10
Pierre Sprey, part of the original design team to create one of the most iconic aircraft flying today, tells the unusual story of how it came to be.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
$21 Billion Worth of Concurrency Orphans?
Congress has authorized—and the Pentagon has spent—nearly $40 billion purchasing approximately 189 F-35s that, in their current configuration, will never be able to perform the way they were expected to when taxpayer dollars were used to buy them.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Don Vandergriff on Military Personnel Reform
Don Vandergriff, a retired soldier and author, has dedicated his career to promoting the concept of Mission Command and to advocating for the kind of institutional reforms necessary to see the concept fully realized.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Dr. Bruce Gudmundsson on Military History
Dr. Bruce Gudmundsson speaks to CDI’s Dan Grazier about military history.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Mark Thompson’s Military Industrial Circus
Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Mark Thompson has a 4 decade-long perspective covering the Pentagon. He brings this experience to the Center for Defense Information and POGO with his new column, the Military Industrial Circus.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Dr. Tim Kane’s Total Volunteer Force
Dr. Tim Kane speaks to CDI’s Dan Grazier about his recommendations to modernize the Pentagon’s antiquated personnel system.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
The Creation of Warfighting, with John Schmitt
When the Marine Corps needed a new capstone document to capture its emerging warfighting philosophy in the 1980s, the person chosen to draft it was not a general, but a junior officer, then-captain John Schmitt.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
When Pilots Can’t Fly, with Maj. Carl Forsling (USMC Ret.)
Maj. Carl Forsling (USMC), a retired CH-46 and MV-22 Osprey pilot, discusses the effects of reduced flying hours on the readiness and morale of our nation’s military pilots.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Winslow Wheeler on Congressional Oversight
Winslow Wheeler, a veteran Capitol Hill staffer, shares his insights about what proper Congressional oversight is and provides tips for today’s young staffers on how they can be most effective in their roles providing national security oversight.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Bill Lind on the Congressional Military Reform Caucus
Former national security advisor to former Senator Gary Hart Bill Lind discusses the once formidable Congressional Military Reform Caucus.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Program Helps Marine Officers Develop Decision-Making Skills
New Marine Corps officers are developing their decision-making skills using methods originally created to train the nation’s top business leaders.Listen Now
