COVID-19 and the Constitution S01
Archived
Surveillance in a Pandemic: Preserving Civil Liberties
This podcast series is no longer active and is preserved as an archive below.
Hosted by
In this virtual briefing, we examine surveillance measures in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. The discussion looks at the obstacles to effective contact tracing systems, and what principles should guide the government if it does choose to enact public health surveillance measures as part of its pandemic response.
Some key takeaways include:
- Surveillance is unlikely to provide much value in the United States until testing dramatically improves: Without a quick and robust testing system it will be impossible to create an effective contact tracing system, even with intensive surveillance measures.
- Cell phone tracking faces significant technical hurdles: Measures currently being considered, such as the Apple and Google Bluetooth project, have a limited ability to accurately identify the types of contacts that pose a high risk of infection, which could lead to an ineffective system that generates false alarms and loses the public’s trust.
- Surveillance programs must have guardrails: There are numerous limits that could be placed on any surveillance measures to protect civil liberties and prevent mission creep, such as prohibiting use other than for public health purposes and creating a timeline for deleting data.
- There are lessons we can learn from other countries that are enacting a variety of surveillance measures. Some of those programs may be effective, but others appear more designed to facilitate draconian enforcement and support repressive regimes.
Show Notes
Jake Laperruque - Speaker
Michael Osterholm - Guest Speaker
Deborah Brown - Guest Speaker
Greg Nojeim - Guest Speaker
-
S01
Archived
COVID-19 and the First Amendment: Challenges to Speech and Religious Activity
In this week’s briefing, experts on First Amendment rights examine the range of questions raised for freedom of speech and religion created by COVID-19, especially as social distancing measures strain public activities and interactions.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
COVID-19 and Immigration: Protecting Immigrant Rights and Safety
The COVID-19 pandemic is creating serious public health risks. Our panel of experts explains why the threat of the virus is so severe in these immigration detention facilities, and how we can reduce them.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Pretrial Detention and Access to Courts: How to Safeguard Liberty and Justice During COVID-19
In this briefing, we examine how the criminal justice system is responding to the COVID-19 pandemic, and the dangers it poses to the rights of the accused and how it could endanger thier lives.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
Surveillance in a Pandemic: Preserving Civil Liberties
As governments consider new surveillance measures to respond to COVID-19, we bring together medical and civil liberties experts to examine what will and won't be effective and how to preserve civil liberties.Listen Now -
S01
Archived
COVID-19 Travel Restrictions: Protecting Public Health without Eroding Civil Liberties
In this virtual briefing, we examine travel limits in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, what powers the government has, and how policies should be designed to protect public health and while also safeguarding fundamental rights.Listen Now
