POGO Asks Congress to Request DOJ Ethics Guidance to Acting Attorney General Whitaker

Delivered to the Chairs and Ranking Members of the House and Senate Judiciary and Appropriations Committees.

Dear Chairman Grassley, Ranking Member Feinstein, Chairman Goodlatte, and Ranking Member Nadler; Chairman Moran, Ranking Member Shaheen, Chairman Culberson, and Ranking Member Serrano:

I am writing to ask that you request access to, and release to the public, any advice or guidance Department of Justice ethics officials gave Acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker about his ability to oversee the ongoing investigation into Russian interference with the 2016 presidential election, led by Special Counsel Robert Mueller.

President Donald Trump appointed Mr. Whitaker on November 7, 2018, after announcing the resignation of former Attorney General Jeff Sessions.¹ As you know, Mr. Sessions recused himself from overseeing the Russia investigation, leaving oversight to Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein.²

Mr. Whitaker’s public comments regarding the Special Counsel’s investigation and his ties to a grand jury witness in this investigation, which have been widely reported, raise legitimate questions about whether he will be able to oversee the investigation fairly.

1. Mr. Whitaker stated that the President can order the Attorney General and FBI to initiate or terminate any investigation on an at-will basis. He also stated that President Trump would have been within his rights to order then-FBI Director James Comey to terminate the FBI investigation into former National Security Advisor Michael Flynn.³
2. Mr. Whitaker served as Chairman for the 2014 campaign of Mr. Sam Clovis for the position of Iowa State Treasurer.⁴ Mr. Clovis is now a grand jury witness in the Special Counsel’s investigation.⁵ Department of Justice regulations prohibit Mr. Whitaker’s involvement in the investigation in light of this relationship.⁶
3. Mr. Whitaker published an opinion piece for CNN on August 6, 2017, entitled “Mueller’s investigation of Trump is going too far.” In it, he advocates for limiting the scope of the Special Counsel’s investigation.⁷ 

Mr. Whitaker’s comments and conflict of interest create serious cause for concern regarding his willingness to remain independent. As Members of Congress with jurisdiction over appropriations for the Department of Justice, you are in a position to ensure that the Department has adequately considered these issues, and to show the American people what those considerations were.

The position of Attorney General demands indisputable independence and integrity, which is why any candidate to fill the seat must be thoroughly vetted by the Senate regarding questions of character and possible conflicts of interest.

President Trump’s temporary placement of Mr. Whitaker circumvented the oversight role of the Senate’s vetting process. Given Mr. Whitaker’s past comments and his relationship with a grand jury witness to the investigation, it is essential is any guidance from ethics officials about his potential involvement in the investigation be presented to the public.

Sincerely,

Danielle Brian
Executive Director