Bad Watchdog Season 2 launches June 20.

Policy Letter

POGO Joins in Recommendations to Obama on Crisis Management

President Barack Obama

The White House

1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

Washington, DC 20500

Dear President Obama:

As you know all too well, we live in a world where crises are unpredictable and unavoidable. Whether it is a catastrophic oil spill, an overwhelming weather event, a terrorist attack, or a major outbreak of food-borne illness, we rely on our government to help us cope.

The Union of Concerned Scientists Center for Science and Democracy recently convened a diverse group of experts working on openness and transparency, as well as public health and crisis information management.

Together, we’ve put together a list of core values that we hope will guide your administration in the future. Our goal is to ensure that the public has the information they need to protect themselves and their families as rapidly and comprehensively as possible. We hope that we can work with you to adopt the following core recommendations:

1) Elevate the Federal Emergency Management Agency Administrator to special assistant to the President to highlight FEMA’s crucial role in managing crises.

2) Give the FEMA Administrator the power to release confidential business information to the public when the public health and safety requires such an exemption.

3) Issue an executive order requiring executive agencies to come up with structures and methods of communicating information about crises that span all federal agencies, and that identify the appropriate crisis information managers at the state and local level.

4) Create an interagency federal advisory panel including experts from outside the government, particularly from non-profits such as the Red Cross, to both help structure a sound and effective crisis information management plan, and evaluate how well the government performed and what could be improved after major crises occur.

5) Ask your Chief Technology Officer to work with agencies to develop systems for using social media to inform the public about developing crises.

6) Institute a crisis matrix that establishes priorities for the dissemination of information. The highest priority should be giving the public plain-language information about how to prepare for and react to a crisis.

7) Find ways to communicate risk in ways that resonate. A good example is the weather service’s designation of storms and hurricanes.

8) Disclose information about the health and public safety impacts of a crisis as you receive it, making clear that the facts may change as the science becomes more conclusive.

9) Invite scientists outside government to help with risk assessments and publicly disclose and make available for public comment as much of this information as possible.

10) Take steps to respond in a timely manner to media requests for information and interviews and make every effort to grant the media access to experts and government officials with the greatest firsthand knowledge or expertise about the crisis.

We will be developing more detailed information and recommendations to share with your staff in the months ahead. We look forward to working with you on this important issue.


Prudence S. Adler

Associate Executive Director

Association of Research Libraries

Rick Bissell

Professor and Graduate Program Director

UMBC Department of Emergency Health Services

Baltimore, MD 21250

Caroline Smith DeWaal

Food Safety Director

Center for Science in the Public Interest

Angela Canterbury

Director of Public Policy

Project On Government Oversight

Mark R. Caramanica

FOI Director

The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press

Patrice McDermott

Executive Director

Andrew Rosenberg


Center for Science and Democracy

Union of Concerned Scientists